REVIEWER GUIDELINES

High Standards. Fair Reviews. Stronger Research.

These guidelines help ensure a consistent, fair, and constructive review process for all ResearchBack papers and external journal/conference review requests.

Academic Integrity
Academic Integrity
Independent Evaluation
Independent Evaluation
Constructive Feedback
Constructive Feedback
A Stronger Research Community
A Stronger Research Community
Academic Integrity
Academic Integrity
Independent Evaluation
Independent Evaluation
Constructive Feedback
Constructive Feedback
A Stronger Research Community
A Stronger Research Community
High Standards. Fair Reviews. Stronger Research.

Our Core Principles

Every review on ResearchBack is guided by the following principles.

Integrity

Provide objective, honest, and unbiased evaluations.

Confidentiality

Treat all manuscripts and materials as strictly confidential.

Constructive Feedback

Provide clear, respectful, and actionable comments to help authors improve their work.

Fairness

Base your review on scientific merit, not personal beliefs, competition, or conflicts of interest.

Contribution

Support high-quality research and the global research community.

Detailed Reviewer Guidelines

Please follow these guidelines when accepting and completing a review.

1. Before Accepting a Review

  • Ensure the manuscript is within your area of expertise.
  • Check for any potential conflicts of interest.
  • Accept only if you can complete the review within the requested timeline.

2. During the Review

  • Evaluate the originality, methodology, validity, and significance of the work.
  • Provide clear, detailed, and respectful feedback.
  • Support your comments with evidence and references where possible.
  • Maintain a professional and constructive tone.

3. Your Review Report

  • Be clear, specific, and well-structured.
  • Highlight strengths as well as areas for improvement.
  • Provide actionable suggestions.
  • Avoid personal remarks or unprofessional language.

4. Confidentiality

  • Do not share, distribute, or discuss the manuscript with others.
  • Do not use information from the manuscript for your own research before publication.
  • Maintain confidentiality even after the review is completed.

5. Conflicts of Interest

  • Declare any potential conflicts of interest (e.g., personal, financial, institutional).
  • If a conflict exists, decline the review request.
  • Inform the ResearchBack team if a conflict arises during the review process.

6. Timeliness

  • Complete your review within the agreed deadline.
  • If you cannot meet the deadline, notify the team as soon as possible.
  • Timely reviews help maintain an efficient and fair process for authors and other reviewers.

Additional Resources

Find useful resources to support your review work.

Need Help?

If you have any questions about these guidelines or a specific review request, contact our peer review team.

Contact Us
Better Reviews
A Brighter Tomorrow

Ready to Start Reviewing?

Join the ResearchBack reviewer community and get paid for your expertise while making a real impact on global research.

Apply as a Reviewer